Will CAPE Phase 3 Refund Finally Liquidated IEEPA Entries?
Finally liquidated IEEPA entries remain outside a general CAPE Phase 3 lane. Compare protective protests, CIT review, and the latest CBP refund posture.
If you got pulled into IEEPA tariffs in 2025 and your customs broker recently told you the entries have been “finally liquidated” or are “in suspended liquidation,” you have probably already discovered that CAPE Phase 1 will not refund you. The April 28 CIT order made this explicit: CBP confirmed that finally liquidated entries and certain suspended entries are excluded from Phase 1. The CBP says its plaintiff-specific Phase 3 workflow deployed October 6 after the earlier validation delay. It covers finally liquidated entries with CIT reliquidation orders, with rolling cohort access (a valid IOR number supplied by August 27, 2026 as of the November 10 declaration). Class counsel’s November 10 motion for a class-wide relief order is pending; neither it nor the October 8 certification has ordered refunds. See the Phase 3 eligibility checklist and the Freestyle World case update.
That does not mean payment is automatic. The government continues to dispute whether CBP can refund finally liquidated entries for importers that have not filed their own CIT actions. This post explains the Phase 3 timeline, the legal dispute, and when CIT litigation remains the realistic preservation path.

What “Finally Liquidated” Actually Means
In customs terminology, an entry goes through a sequence: filed, accepted, liquidated, and finally liquidated. Liquidation is when CBP closes the books on the duty calculation for that entry. By default it happens automatically about 314 days after acceptance. Once liquidation happens, importers have a 180-day protest window under 19 USC 1514 to challenge the duty amount.
If no protest is filed in that window, the entry becomes finally liquidated. That status is more than just a label. It means CBP treats the duty calculation as administratively final, the entry is closed in CBP’s accounting system, and the agency has no built-in mechanism to reopen it for refund.
For IEEPA-period entries — between February 1, 2025 and February 24, 2026 — this matters because the IEEPA tariffs were not struck down until the Supreme Court ruled in Learning Resources, Inc. v. Trump on February 20, 2026. By that date, many entries from early 2025 had already liquidated and the protest window had already expired. Those entries are now finally liquidated, and CAPE Phase 1 cannot reach them.
What “Suspended Liquidation” Means
Suspended liquidation is the opposite problem. The entry is not yet liquidated because CBP has paused the liquidation clock. Common reasons:
- The merchandise is subject to a pending antidumping or countervailing duty proceeding at the Department of Commerce
- CBP has an open investigation into the entry (valuation, classification, or origin questions)
- The entry is part of a court-ordered suspension related to other litigation
- The merchandise is held under a pending exclusion order from another agency
Because CAPE Phase 1 needs entries that can be liquidated or reliquidated through the normal weekly cycle, and suspended entries cannot, CBP excluded them from Phase 1 procedurally. The April 28 CIT order specifically called out “certain suspended entries” as outside Phase 1 scope.
For IEEPA exposure on suspended entries, the practical question is: when will the suspension lift, and will the entry then fall within a future CAPE phase window? Often the answer is uncertain enough that waiting passively is the wrong move.
Why CIT Is the Real Refund Path
The Court of International Trade has subject matter jurisdiction over IEEPA refund claims under 28 USC 1581(i) — the residual jurisdiction provision. This is the same statutory basis that produced the Learning Resources and Genova Pipe decisions that struck down the IEEPA tariffs in the first place.
CIT jurisdiction has two important features that distinguish it from CBP protests:
- A separate deadline from the 180-day protest window. Under 28 USC 2636(i), a 1581(i) action is generally due within two years after its cause of action first accrues. The statute does not identify a uniform accrual date for IEEPA refund claims or name the February 20, 2026 Learning Resources decision as a universal trigger. An October 19 analysis identifies possible country-specific periods beginning in February, March, or April 2027, and notes that earlier-liquidating entries may require earlier action. These are legal analyses, not a ruling that settles accrual for every entry. Do not assume all claims remain open through 2028. Ask counsel to calculate the deadline for each entry and claim theory. (28 USC 2636(i); October 19 analysis)
- CBP cannot dispose of the claim administratively. Unlike a protest, which CBP decides on, a CIT case is decided by Article III judges. CBP’s determination that an entry is “finally liquidated” does not bind CIT.
The downside is cost and timing. CIT cases involve filing fees, attorney fees, and potentially years of litigation. They make economic sense when IEEPA exposure on the affected entries justifies the spend.
Who Should Be Talking to CIT Counsel Now
Two profiles where CIT consultation is high priority:
Profile 1: Large IEEPA exposure, finally liquidated entries. If you imported significant volume from China, Canada, Mexico, or Venezuela-oil countries between February and roughly August 2025, your earliest entries are likely finally liquidated by now. If your aggregate IEEPA duty payment on those finally liquidated entries is in the high six figures or above, the CIT math typically works.
Profile 2: Suspended entries with no clear suspension end date. If you have entries on AD/CVD suspension that may not lift for years, waiting for CAPE Phase 2 is functionally waiting indefinitely. CIT lets you preserve the IEEPA refund claim without depending on when the AD/CVD case resolves.
For both profiles, the first step is a counsel review of your actual liquidation status. Many importers think their entries are “still open” but are wrong because of how CBP’s automated liquidation works.
What to Document Before Calling Counsel
Pull these from ACE before the conversation:
- Entry summary report covering February 2025 through August 2025 (the window most likely to contain finally liquidated entries)
- Liquidation status indicator for each entry
- IEEPA Chapter 99 duty lines on each entry (HTS 9903.01.25 through 9903.01.70)
- For suspended entries: the suspension reason code and any related CBP or Commerce case numbers
- Aggregate IEEPA duty paid by entry status (open, liquidated within 80 days, finally liquidated, suspended)
Our pre-counsel documentation checklist covers the standard package; for finally liquidated and suspended entries, add the liquidation-status detail above.
Don’t Skip the Protest Backstop on Anything Still Open
Even while you are evaluating CIT for finally liquidated entries, file protective protests under 19 USC 1514 on every entry that is still within the 180-day window from liquidation. Protest filing is inexpensive insurance that prevents your other entries from also becoming finally liquidated and joining the CIT-only category. Our protest filing guide walks through the mechanics, and the CAPE-vs-protest-vs-CIT decision flow shows how the three paths fit together.
How CIT Cases Have Played Out So Far
The IEEPA refund litigation track record is short but favorable to importers:
- Genova Pipe v. Lutnick and Noem (CIT, May 28, 2025) — first major ruling that IEEPA tariffs exceeded statutory authority
- Learning Resources, Inc. v. Trump (Supreme Court, February 20, 2026, 6-3) — definitive ruling that IEEPA does not authorize tariffs
- Nintendo of America Inc. v. U.S. Department of the Treasury (filed March 2026) — refund recovery action currently pending
The legal theory is settled. What is being litigated now is the procedural question of which importers can recover and through what mechanism. Importers who file at CIT now are in the early wave of refund-recovery cases, which generally moves faster than later waves.
Update — June 7, 2026: DOJ Appeal Reinforces the CIT-First Posture
The May 27 show-cause order briefly raised the odds that CBP might be pushed into a broader administrative refund path for finally liquidated entries. The June appeal posture cuts the other way. Davis Wright Tremaine reports that DOJ appealed the CIT refund order and sought a stay of the universal refund requirement, while Thompson Hine reports the administration appealed the CIT’s IEEPA tariff refund order.
For finally liquidated entries, the practical reading is conservative:
- Do not assume Phase 2 will reopen final liquidations. The appeal is aimed at limiting or pausing universal refund relief while the Federal Circuit reviews the CIT order.
- Plaintiff status matters more. DWT summarizes the government’s position as distinguishing between importers that filed timely lawsuits and importers that have not sued.
- Protests still matter where available. If a related entry is liquidated but still inside the 180-day window, a protective protest remains the lower-cost preservation step.
- CIT review should happen before waiting. If the exposure is material and the protest window is closed, ask counsel whether a 28 USC 1581(i) complaint is still available for your entry set.
This update does not mean every finally liquidated entry needs litigation. It does mean “wait for CAPE Phase 2” is now a weaker default for high-value claims.
Update — June 18, 2026: Phase 3 Technology Targeted for Late July
- At the June 9 CIT hearing, CBP said Phase 3 programming for finally liquidated entries is expected to be ready in late July 2026. Source: Thompson Hine, Holland & Knight, Husch Blackwell, and Green Worldwide summaries of the hearing.
- CBP indicated that importer-of-record identifiers will be required to route Phase 3 refunds and reduce payment errors.
- The government’s legal position remains that finally liquidated refunds for non-litigants require importer-specific court authority. The Federal Circuit appeal has not resolved that issue.
- A working system therefore does not guarantee universal payment. Importers with material exposure should ask counsel whether a CIT action is appropriate and should continue filing protective protests for related entries still inside the 180-day window.
Update — July 17, 2026: Court Says Phase 3 and Open-Protest Work Continue
The Court of International Trade’s July 15 order provides the clearest current status, and it is more limited than a Phase 3 launch announcement:
- The court said development of CAPE Phase 3 is ongoing.
- It said the court will enter a future order directing CBP to reliquidate certain finally liquidated entries under a procedure that will be outlined in that order. The order is expected to be entered in approximately 3,700 IEEPA cases assigned to the court.
- The court also discussed further CAPE functionality to process refunds for entries with open protests; that functionality is likewise still being developed.
There is not yet a published Phase 3 eligibility list, operational filing lane, or automatic reliquidation rule. Do not withdraw a protective protest or defer a material CIT analysis solely because of this anticipated work. For entries with an active protest, review the open-protest CAPE guide alongside the CAPE, protest, and CIT decision guide. Source: CIT, July 15, 2026 order.
Update - July 20, 2026: Lead Case Shifts to Freestyle World; Class-Certification Motion Pending
Two developments change the finally-liquidated outlook, and both trace to the CIT’s July 15 order (ECF No. 46) and the July 13 Lord Declaration (ECF No. 45):
- The lead case is changing. Euro-Notions Florida, Inc. filed a voluntary notice of dismissal on July 16, 2026 (ECF No. 48) under USCIT Rule 41(a)(1)(A)(i). The July 15 order had already disclosed the plan: the court will lift the stay in Freestyle World, Inc. v. United States, Court No. 26-01088, and use it as the new lead case. Freestyle World has a motion for class certification currently pending under Rule 23. The court also discussed the Rule 23 schedule in V.O.S. Selections, Inc. v. United States, No. 25-00066.
- A certified class could change the non-litigant calculus. The government has maintained that finally-liquidated refunds for importers who did not sue require individual CIT complaints. If the court certifies a plaintiff class in Freestyle World, importers within the class definition could potentially recover without filing their own suits. Certification is not guaranteed and the government is expected to oppose it.
- Updated pipeline figures. The July 13 Lord Declaration reports approximately $121.75 billion accepted for CAPE processing and $86.3 billion sent to Treasury as of July 10, with 9,837 refunds still blocked by missing ACH information.
- Phase 3 is still in development. The court reiterated that it will enter a future order directing CBP to reliquidate certain finally liquidated entries in each of approximately 3,700 IEEPA cases assigned to the court, under a procedure not yet published.
The practical posture is unchanged: do not withdraw a protective protest or defer a material CIT analysis solely because of the Freestyle World class motion or anticipated Phase 3 work. If you have material finally-liquidated exposure, ask counsel whether an individual 28 USC 1581(i) complaint is appropriate while the class question is unresolved. Full breakdown: IEEPA Refund Case Shifts to Freestyle World as CAPE Pipeline Reaches $121.75B.
Update — July 23, 2026: Judge Eaton Orders Reliquidation of Finally Liquidated Entries for Plaintiffs
On July 17, 2026, Judge Eaton issued a reliquidation order (ECF No. 52) that is the most significant court action to date for finally liquidated IEEPA entries:
- The order directs CBP to reliquidate, without regard to IEEPA duties, all entries that have been liquidated for more than 80 days and on which plaintiffs made estimated IEEPA deposits. This includes both finally liquidated entries and entries that may become final while being processed by CAPE.
- The order applies to plaintiffs in the approximately 3,700 IEEPA cases assigned to the court. Importers who did not file a CIT lawsuit are not covered by this order.
- Plaintiffs must submit their importer of record identification numbers to CBP. Instructions describing how to make this submission will be sent to plaintiffs’ counsel. Plaintiffs need not take any further action to receive these instructions.
- Once instructions are received and followed, a CAPE declaration may be submitted. More than one CAPE declaration may be submitted, particularly for entries that become finally liquidated subsequent to the filing of the initial declaration.
- The court kept cases stayed except to the extent the order directs specific actions. Plaintiffs who need further assistance may move to lift the stay and file a motion to reconsider.
- The court assumes that a majority of plaintiffs will have already used CAPE for eligible entries and anticipates that plaintiffs who have received all relief sought will move to voluntarily dismiss their cases.
This order provides the legal authority that CBP had said it needed to reliquidate finally liquidated entries. The practical next step for plaintiffs is to wait for CBP’s instructions to counsel and then submit IOR identification numbers and CAPE declarations. For importers who are not plaintiffs in any of the 3,700+ cases, the Freestyle World class-certification motion (if granted) could potentially extend a similar path, but certification is not guaranteed.
Do not withdraw a protective protest or defer CIT counsel review solely because of this order. The order helps litigating plaintiffs; it does not yet create a general administrative path for non-litigants. Full analysis: CIT Orders CBP to Reliquidate Finally Liquidated IEEPA Entries. Source: CIT, In re Tariffs Collected in Reliance on IEEPA, July 17, 2026 reliquidation order (ECF No. 52).
Update — August 5, 2026: Reliquidation Order Entered in 3,700+ Cases; Pipeline Tops $100B
- The August 5, 2026 CIT order (ECF No. 25) confirms the July 17 reliquidation order has now been entered in more than 3,700 IEEPA cases. The court set CBP’s next CAPE progress report for August 25 and a settlement conference for August 26. Source: Order, August 5, 2026 (ECF No. 25).
- CBP’s August 4, 2026 Lord Declaration reports approximately $128.68 billion accepted for CAPE processing and approximately $100 billion sent to Treasury as of July 31, with 19,726 refunds (about $1.6 billion) still held for missing ACH information. Source: Lord Declaration, August 4, 2026 (ECF No. 24).
- The reliquidation path still applies only to plaintiffs in the court-assigned cases. Non-litigant importers are not covered, so the Freestyle World class-certification motion (oral argument August 19) remains the principal open question for non-plaintiffs.
Update — August 20, 2026: Federal Circuit Appeal Brief Reinforces Plaintiff-Specific Relief
On August 10, 2026, DOJ filed its opening brief in the consolidated Federal Circuit appeal, Appeal No. 26-1895. The brief asks the appellate court to vacate the CIT’s universal injunctions and argues that broader relief for importers who are not parties to the litigation exceeds the court’s authority. Source: DOJ opening brief, August 10, 2026.
- DOJ’s filing says CBP has processed and certified approximately $100 billion in CAPE refunds as of July 31, 2026, and will comply with party-specific court orders for finally liquidated entries.
- The brief is not a decision. It does not create a general Phase 3 filing lane, resolve the Freestyle World class-certification motion, or eliminate the need to preserve protest rights.
- For non-litigants with finally liquidated entries, the practical posture remains unsettled: keep any available protest strategy under review and ask trade counsel whether an individual 28 USC 1581(i) action is appropriate for material exposure.
The appeal therefore strengthens the reason to separate plaintiff-specific reliquidation relief from any future program for non-litigants. Do not treat a pending appeal or a possible class remedy as a substitute for a deadline-driven review of your own entries.
Update — August 23, 2026: Phase 3 Delayed Without a New Opening Date
- An August 19 report at IEEPATariffRefunds.info says CBP told the CIT it could not roll out CAPE Phase 3 as planned and could not provide an opening date. A separate August 21 report from Diaz Trade Law describes Phase 3 as delayed until further notice and cites International Trade Today.
- These are secondary reports, not an official CBP deployment CSMS. CBP’s public IEEPA page still lists Phase 1 and Phase 2 as the active phases. The July 17 reliquidation order remains plaintiff-specific; it is not a general administrative path for non-litigants.
- Counsel should confirm any limitation or protest deadline for the particular entry set. Professional analyses have identified possible 2027 milestones for some tariff periods, including February 4 and April 5, 2027, but accrual, tolling, and the correct filing path are fact-specific and should not be assumed from a general date.
What to Watch Going Forward
As of October 14, the October 13 closed-conference date had passed, but accessible public docket material did not verify whether the conference occurred or any outcome. The parties’ proposed scheduling order is due October 22; CBP’s next progress report is due October 26 at 5 p.m. Eastern, followed by a closed conference October 27 at 2 p.m. Eastern. Do not treat class certification as a refund order or general CAPE instruction.
Update — August 27, 2026: Phase 3 Confirmed as Plaintiff-Specific and Delayed
- CBP says Phase 3 covers finally liquidated entries filed by plaintiffs for which the CIT has ordered reliquidation. Source: August 25 Lord Declaration, ECF No. 38.
- Deployment is temporarily delayed while CBP builds validations that prevent adjustments outside the IEEPA refund and account for improperly reported IEEPA duties on original entries.
- The filing does not establish a general Phase 3 route for non-litigants. Importers with material finally liquidated exposure should obtain case-specific CIT advice instead of relying on a possible future class or administrative lane.
- For entries still within 180 days of liquidation, continue evaluating protective protests; CAPE development and court proceedings do not pause that deadline.
Update — September 22, 2026: October 6 Target Is Plaintiff-Specific
- CBP’s September 15 Lord Declaration, ECF No. 50 says the limited Phase 3 deployment is planned for October 6. The first filing group consists of plaintiffs whose finally liquidated entries have court-ordered reliquidation and whose valid IOR number reached CBP by July 30; later submitters await instructions.
- The September 17 CIT order, ECF No. 52 requires a progress report October 6 and sets a closed conference October 7. Neither the order nor the deployment plan creates a general non-plaintiff lane.
- For entries still within 180 days of liquidation, preserve available protest rights; for material finally liquidated claims outside the plaintiff group, obtain case-specific CIT advice rather than waiting for a possible class ruling.
Update — October 14, 2026: Limited Phase 3 and Class Certification
- CBP says Phase 3 deployed at 5:10 a.m. Eastern October 6 for finally liquidated entries covered by CIT reliquidation orders. The first cohort supplied valid IOR numbers by July 30; later submitters await instructions. Source: ECF No. 58.
- The October 8 Freestyle World opinion certified a Rule 23(b)(2) class, but did not itself award refunds, direct reliquidation, or establish a CAPE filing process for class members.
- Under ECF No. 60, the next CBP CAPE report is due October 26 at 5 p.m. Eastern and a closed conference is set for October 27 at 2 p.m. Eastern. The parties’ proposed schedule is due October 22.
- Continue to preserve available protest rights and seek case-specific counsel review. A class definition or a Phase 3 deployment does not by itself resolve an importer’s eligibility or payment status.
Update — October 22, 2026: CIT Filing Deadlines Remain Entry-Specific
- Section 2636(i) sets a two-year period from when a cause of action first accrues, but it does not determine when an IEEPA refund claim accrues. Attorney analyses differ; the October 19 Greenberg Traurig alert discusses possible country-specific timing beginning in February-April 2027 and warns that some entries may liquidate earlier. These views do not establish a court-approved deadline. Do not rely on a uniform February 20, 2026 start date or assume a 2028 deadline; have counsel assess each entry and preserve any available protest rights separately.
- The October 8 Freestyle World opinion certified a class but did not order class-wide refunds or create a CAPE filing procedure. The parties’ proposed schedule is due October 22 under ECF No. 60; its filing status was not verified in the accessible public record checked for this update. The next CAPE report is due October 26 at 5 p.m. Eastern, with a closed conference set for October 27 at 2 p.m. Eastern.
Watch our CSMS message index and the CAPE Update Tracker on the home page for new official checkpoints.
If you have material IEEPA exposure on finally liquidated or suspended entries, request a free assessment and we will connect you with vetted trade counsel who handles CIT 1581(i) refund litigation specifically.